Scarce growth — Can the tortoises continue to outpace the hares?

Global Perspectives Blog
  • Recent selloff has tested stance that investors would benefit from seeking scarce growth, so long as that growth did not become wildly overvalued.
  • We appear to be moving into a “sorting out” stage where investors begin to more granularly assess both the fundamentals and the incremental opportunities.
  • Patience and tolerance for ongoing bouts of volatility are crucial, but we believe that investors who focus on the underlying fundamentals will ultimately be rewarded.

For some time we have suggested that in a world slowly recovering from the 2008 financial crisis, aggregate global growth would be sub-par and that investors would benefit from seeking scarce growth, so long as that growth did not become wildly overvalued. Recent market action has tested that stance severely. Beginning in March we have seen a violent style rotation featuring the selloff of stocks with high price momentum and high growth characteristics. This was not solely a phenomenon within the U.S. equity markets (Exhibit 1). There is significant evidence that the hedge fund community has been particularly hard hit in this reversal, exacerbating the issue as levered portfolios have been forced to liquidate assets, fueling ongoing pressure on many “growthier” segments. So, where do we go from here? Is it time to seek market shelter, or has this sell-off created opportunity?

Exhibit 1: Price momentum performance, one-year prior vs. March-April selloff


Note: Factor returns are represented by the quintile spreads (not sector neutral, top 20% - bottom 20%, √Benchmark Weights weighted, in USD).

Given the pain this reversal has caused, there has been a scramble for strategists and market commentators to isolate a root cause. Generally, the diagnosis has centered on concerns of 1) slowing global growth, 2) “crowdedness” in the higher growth sectors and 3) valuation. In considering the potential duration of this flight to safety, let me briefly address each of these issues. While we have already felt a significant shift, these sorts of factor regime shifts can be quite persistent (Exhibit 2). However, we appear to be moving into a “sorting out” stage where investors begin to more granularly assess both the fundamentals and the incremental opportunities.


Global growth concerns: There have been data points of concern regarding global growth of late with 1Q U.S. gross domestic product (GDP) extremely anemic, a continued slowdown in Chinese growth and generally uninspiring revenue reports from 1Q earnings in the U.S. and even more so in Europe. However, we continue to see a slow, steady improvement in U.S. growth (evidenced more clearly by the employment data) and a continuation of enough growth in the rest of the developed world to maintain forward progress, but not so much that we lose the support of central bank stimulus. All in all, an environment that continues to support not a “rising tide lifts all boats” outlook, but a world in which organic growers and innovators can stand out and trade over time at reasonable premiums.

“Crowdedness”: In short, if there was crowded trade in higher growth sectors, that ship has sailed. The recent performance pain and related hedge fund liquidations would appear to have significantly reduced that concern. Also, where we had seen modest evidence of market “froth” in the form of frenetic IPO issuance in certain sectors, the pullback seems to have slowed the calendar and applied a higher quality hurdle.

Valuation: Trading at a P/E ratio of around 15X current earnings, the market is in-line with historic averages and does not appear overvalued. However, considering the historically low interest rate environment, equities look remarkably inexpensive compared to fixed income alternatives (including even debt from the same issuer). As for the valuations of premium growers relative to the rest of the market, our work suggests that statistically, the top growers have given back most of their P/E expansion relative to the broader market in this sell-off. So, we do not see overall valuations or the specific valuations of high growers in general as a major issue.

Finally, I would note two things about growth investing. First, exciting things are happening around innovative software, cloud computing applications, industrial automation and biotechnology; these areas are gaining significant share of their broader global industries with real advances in productivity and effectiveness. These are nothing like the “all hype, no substance” companies and concepts we saw during the internet bubble. We don’t see anything broadly in 1Q results to dissuade us from this view; particularly in biotechnology, we have been encouraged by the ground level results, despite the market action. Ultimately, earnings growth is still a powerful driver of longer term investment results and in a world where overall growth appears as if it may remain modest for some time to come, share-gaining innovation remains attractive. Second, not all “growth” names are created equal. As is usually the case in major factor reversals, after an initial surge that does not differentiate between individual stories, there is a “sorting out” period where more fundamental differences at the company by company level become discernable to the markets. Not all Internet and biotech names are created equal and the homogenous ill treatment of these sectors in the last two months creates stock-picking opportunities. Patience and tolerance for ongoing bouts of volatility are crucial in this period, but we believe that those disciplined enough to focus on the underlying fundamentals will ultimately be rewarded.

Tagged with: Equities, Investing, Markets

About the Contributor

The views expressed in this material are the views of the author through the date of publication and are subject to change without notice at any time based upon market and other factors. All information has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable, but its accuracy is not guaranteed. There is no representation or warranty as to the current accuracy, reliability or completeness of, nor liability for, decisions based on such information and it should not be relied on as such. This information may contain certain statements that may be deemed forward-looking statements. Please note that any such statements are not guarantees of any future performance and actual results or developments may differ materially from those discussed. There is no guarantee that investment objectives will be achieved or that any particular investment will be profitable. Past performance does not guarantee future results. This information is not intended to provide investment advice and does not account for individual investor circumstances. Investment decisions should always be made based on an investor's specific financial needs, objectives, goals, time horizon and risk tolerance. Please see our social media guidelines.

About Us

Backed by more than 100 years of experience, Columbia Management is one of the nation’s largest asset managers. At the heart of our success and, most importantly, that of our investors, are highly talented industry professionals, brought together by a unique way of working. At Columbia Management, reaching our performance goals matters, and how we reach them matters just as much.